Discretionary vs. Non-Discretionary Bonuses

What’s the difference?

While a discretionary bonus is a bonus paid at an employer’s discretion, a non-discretionary bonus is paid based on predetermined criteria.  In other words, an employer can use their discretion to decide on an employee’s discretionary bonus, while a non-discretionary bonus is based on previously agreed upon criteria.

A discretionary bonus gives an employer flexibility in rewarding an employee, whereas a non-discretionary bonus adheres to already known factors for determination.  Both types of bonuses serve as incentives to elevate performance, recognize achievements, and retain valuable talent within organizations.  While both serve to acknowledge and reward employees, they operate on distinct principles with implications for employers and employees.

What is a Discretionary Bonus?

a map giving a view on a discretionary bonus

Discretionary bonuses constitute a facet of employment compensation wherein employers possess the latitude to bestow additional remuneration upon employees, contingent upon their judgment and evaluation of various factors. This category of bonuses is characterized by its inherent flexibility, affording employers autonomy in determining the allocation of supplementary compensation beyond standard salary or wages.

Central to the concept of discretionary bonuses is the discretionary authority vested in employers, enabling them to reward exceptional performance, demonstrated loyalty, or other meritorious contributions that may defy quantification through conventional performance metrics. The absence of rigidly defined criteria allows employers to respond dynamically to evolving business exigencies and individual circumstances, thereby fostering a culture of recognition and motivation within the workforce.

Illustrative examples of discretionary bonus scenarios may encompass instances where employees surpass predetermined performance targets, exhibit exemplary dedication to organizational objectives, or make invaluable contributions to project success. In such scenarios, employers wield their discretion to confer bonuses as tokens of appreciation and incentives for sustained excellence.

The discretionary nature of these bonuses grants employers the prerogative to deploy supplementary compensation strategically, tailoring rewards to align with overarching business objectives and values. By leveraging discretionary bonuses judiciously, employers can cultivate an environment conducive to employee engagement, performance optimization, and organizational success.

What is a Non-Discretionary Bonus?

Non-discretionary bonuses are a facet of compensation in which predetermined criteria dictate eligibility and allocation. Unlike discretionary bonuses, which grant employers autonomy in reward distribution, non-discretionary bonuses adhere to predefined standards and performance metrics.

Employers establish clear criteria for non-discretionary bonuses, typically tied to specific performance benchmarks, such as meeting sales targets or achieving project milestones. Employees who fulfill these predetermined criteria are entitled to receive bonuses as outlined in company policies or employment contracts.

Illustrative examples of non-discretionary bonus setups may include sales commissions based on revenue generated, year-end bonuses tied to company profitability, or performance-based incentives linked to individual or team achievements. These bonuses provide employees with tangible incentives to strive for excellence and align their efforts with organizational objectives.

The structured nature of non-discretionary bonuses ensures transparency and fairness in compensation practices, offering employees clear expectations regarding bonus eligibility and allocation. By adhering to predetermined criteria, employers uphold accountability and incentivize performance optimization across the workforce.

Pros and Cons

 Discretionary bonuses offer employers the flexibility to reward exceptional performance or contributions at their discretion, whereas non-discretionary bonuses adhere to predetermined criteria for eligibility and allocation.

When it comes to employee motivation and engagement, both bonus types have distinct effects. Discretionary bonuses can inspire employees by recognizing their efforts in a personalized manner, fostering a sense of appreciation and value within the workforce. On the other hand, non-discretionary bonuses provide clear expectations and a sense of fairness, contributing to transparency and trust in the reward process.

By considering these nuances, employers can tailor their bonus structures to best suit their organizational culture and objectives, ultimately driving employee motivation and engagement towards desired outcomes.

Employees excited about hitting their target with their new rewards program

Discretionary Bonuses Provide Flexibility

Discretionary bonuses offer unique advantages, including the ability to customize rewards based on individual or team achievements, fostering a sense of recognition and appreciation. This flexibility allows employers to adapt bonus allocations to specific circumstances or performance metrics, enhancing their effectiveness as motivational tools.

However, the subjective nature of discretionary bonuses can pose challenges. The lack of clear criteria for awarding bonuses may lead to perceptions of favoritism or inconsistency among employees, potentially undermining morale and trust within the workforce. Additionally, the discretionary nature of these bonuses can make it challenging for employees to anticipate or plan for additional compensation, impacting their overall satisfaction and motivation.

Non-Discretionary Bonuses Provide Structure

Non-discretionary bonuses offer distinct advantages, primarily in terms of transparency and predictability. By adhering to predefined criteria for eligibility and allocation, these bonuses provide employees with clear expectations regarding bonus eligibility and the factors influencing bonus amounts. This transparency fosters a sense of fairness and trust in the reward process, contributing to overall employee satisfaction and engagement.

However, structured bonuses also come with challenges. The rigid nature of non-discretionary bonuses may limit employers’ flexibility in tailoring rewards to individual circumstances or performance metrics. This lack of adaptability can make it difficult to address unique situations or recognize exceptional contributions effectively. Additionally, the predefined criteria for these bonuses may not always align perfectly with evolving business needs or employee motivations, potentially hindering their effectiveness as motivational tools.

discretionary bonus vs performance bonus benefits infographic

When Should You Use Each Type?

Discretionary and non-discretionary bonuses serve essential roles, each tailored to specific use cases that align with organizational objectives and employee motivations.

Discretionary Bonuses

One of the most common use cases for discretionary bonuses is to reward exceptional performance or contributions that exceed standard expectations. Employers may choose to grant discretionary bonuses to employees who go above and beyond their duties, demonstrate exceptional dedication to their work, or achieve outstanding results on a project or task. By offering discretionary bonuses in such instances, employers can reinforce a culture of recognition, motivate employees to maintain high levels of performance, and foster a sense of loyalty and commitment within the workforce.

Additionally, discretionary bonuses can be utilized as retention tools to incentivize key talent to stay with the company. Employers may offer discretionary bonuses to employees who have demonstrated long-term commitment and loyalty, helping to reinforce their value to the organization and encourage continued dedication.

Non-Discretionary Bonuses

Non-discretionary bonuses are commonly used to incentivize employees to achieve specific, predefined performance goals or milestones. These bonuses are typically tied to measurable metrics such as sales targets, production quotas, or project deadlines. By linking bonus eligibility to objective criteria, employers can motivate employees to strive for tangible results that directly contribute to the company’s success.

Another common use case for non-discretionary bonuses is to reward tenure or seniority within the organization. Employers may offer annual or milestone-based bonuses to employees who have reached certain milestones in their tenure, such as years of service or completion of training programs. These bonuses serve to acknowledge employees’ long-term commitment to the organization and provide tangible recognition for their loyalty and dedication.

In summary, discretionary bonuses are often employed to recognize exceptional performance or contributions and incentivize retention, while non-discretionary bonuses are utilized to motivate employees to achieve specific performance goals and reward tenure or seniority within the organization. By understanding the distinct use cases for each type of bonus, employers can effectively leverage both discretionary and non-discretionary bonuses to drive employee engagement, performance, and loyalty.

Which Type Should You Choose?

When navigating between discretionary and non-discretionary bonuses, it’s vital to consider multiple factors. Ask yourself these questions to determine which bonus structure aligns best with your organization’s goals and values:

  1. What are my organization’s goals and objectives, and how do bonus structures align with these goals?
  2. How do I prioritize transparency and fairness in bonus allocation?
  3. What level of control do I want to maintain over bonus distribution?
  4. What type of employee behavior or performance am I seeking to incentivize or reward with the bonus program?
  5. How important is flexibility in bonus allocation?
  6. What level of risks am I willing to take by offering bonuses?
  7. What is the organizational culture like, and how might employees perceive and respond to different bonus structures in terms of motivation, engagement, and satisfaction?

Discretionary bonuses offer a high degree of flexibility, allowing employers to tailor rewards to individual or team achievements. This flexibility can foster a dynamic and adaptive culture within your organization. On the other hand, non-discretionary bonuses provide transparency and predictability, ensuring that employees understand the criteria for earning bonuses and reducing the potential for perceived favoritism.

To make an informed decision, weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each bonus structure against your company’s unique needs and values. Consider the level of control you wish to maintain over bonus allocation, as well as the level of transparency you want to provide to your employees.

Seeking expert guidance from Plentive’s incentive specialists can be instrumental in crafting the right bonus plan for your organization. With their deep expertise and industry insights, they can help you navigate the complexities of bonus structures and design a program that aligns with your company’s objectives while maximizing employee engagement and motivation.

Build your bonus plan

Speak with an expert to create your bonus plan