What is Cash VS Non Cash incentive A Helpful Guide

When it comes to giving incentives or setting up any kind of incentive scheme, managers are faced with several choices. Incentives can take the form of either cash or non-cash incentives. In this article, we’re looking at what is cash vs non- cash incentives a helpful guide, to offer some ideas on what you could be offering your staff.

What is cash vs non cash incentive a helpful guide

Let’s start with a quick answer, then we’ll get into more details.

A cash incentive can be easier to manage, more immediate, and more tangible than non-cash incentives. However, cash incentives can be seen as impersonal, spontaneous, and therefore less valued. It’s difficult to manage large funds if paying a lot of staff and may have financial burdens for employers.

There’s more to it than what we’ve outlined above.

So next, let’s get into the advantages and disadvantages of cash vs non-cash incentives.

What is Cash vs Non cash incentive?

Cash vs non cash incentives

Cash incentives – are monetary rewards such as salary increases, bonus payments, and other forms of direct compensation.

Non-cash incentives – usually involve the provision of goods or services, such as gift cards, vouchers, and discounts on products or services. Both have their advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages of Cash Incentives:

Cash incentives are often easier to manage since they are directly linked to a monetary reward.

They provide employees with an immediate benefit and can be used to cover costs associated with everyday expenses such as transportation, housing, or groceries.

Additionally, cash incentives are usually seen as more tangible rewards than non-cash incentives and their results can often be measured in terms of increased motivation or performance.

Disadvantages of Cash Incentives:

The main disadvantage of cash incentives is that they can be seen as impersonal …since there is no recognition of the individual’s specific accomplishments or achievements.

Additionally, where cash incentives are distributed among a large group of people, it may not have the same impact on each person – due to different individual financial situations and needs.

It also requires greater cash quantities to be handled by admin staff.

Furthermore, cash incentives may not be the most cost-effective option and can result in a high financial burden for employers…

The IRS mandates that taxes be withheld from a bonus payment. This is either at their regular federal withholding rate if paid with an employee’s regular wage, or at the standard 22% supplemental rate.

Additionally, if used without proper consideration of employee morale, cash incentives may create resentment among workers who feel that they’re not being adequately rewarded for the effort they put into their work compared to other staff. Cash rewards can quickly be perceived as unbalanced and disproportionate.

Finally, some workers may feel that cash incentives simply encourage them to do less effort or take shortcuts.

Especially if there are no fixed rules around what performance was achieved to receive the incentive, keeping in mind that productivity is not the same as performance.

All these disadvantages must be taken into consideration when deciding on the best type of incentive system for any business.

Using a dedicated incentive scheme like Plentive, you can get the best available package based on your company staff levels.

Are Cash Incentives Worth It?

If chosen correctly, cash incentives can be an effective way to reward employees and motivate them to work harder and smarter.

Employers should consider the needs of their workforce and carefully weigh up the potential benefits against the associated costs to ensure that they choose the best solution for their business.

When used in combination with other, more organized rewards and recognition systems, cash incentives can have a short-term positive impact on employee motivation and performance.

In today’s competitive business landscape, finding ways to motivate and reward employees is key to success, and cash incentives can be an effective, if not preferred tool in achieving this goal.

Advantages of Non-cash Incentives

The advantages of non-cash incentives like gift cards, vouchers, and other rewards can be more targeted and effective than cash incentives but without the associated costs.

These types of non-cash incentives are often tailored to meet individual needs and preferences for departments or industries, making them more attractive in terms of motivation and recognition.

Planned incentive schemes provide a structured method for management to thank employees for their hard work and dedication while simultaneously providing an incentive to continue performing at a high level.

Disadvantages of Non-cash Incentives

Among the disadvantages of non-cash incentives, we can include the cost associated with purchasing and distributing rewards. If set up correctly, incentive programs can be automated so as not to create additional staff costs.

There is also the risk of not motivating employees due to a lack of understanding or appreciation of the reward itself.

Moreover, non-cash incentives can lead to a perception among some employees that staff members are not valued by their employers. Handing a gift voucher out seems like an afterthought, however, a structured incentive program can seem much more of an intentional approach from management.

In conclusion, non-cash incentives, in general, can be more effective than cash incentives when it comes to rewarding employee performance.

However, employers must assess their goals and objectives before deciding on which type of incentive will be most effective in achieving their desired results.

By taking into consideration the advantages and disadvantages associated with a cash incentive vs non-cash incentive, employers can ensure that they are utilizing the most appropriate type of incentive for their particular needs.

Tailoring an Incentive Program

Incentive programs should also strive to promote company values and culture, as well as be tailored to the individual needs of each employee.

Flexible incentives that are based on rewards such as training opportunities or flexible working hours may be more suitable for certain staff than traditional cash-based incentives.

Employers can use a variety of methods to tailor their incentive plans so that everyone has something to gain from them, including setting weekly or monthly goals for specific tasks or milestones.

This helps managers and executives to keep staff motivated by providing tangible rewards as they progress towards their goals.

Additionally, employers should ensure that they’re regularly engaging with employees to assess the effectiveness of their incentive plans and make any necessary adjustments.

What Makes a Successful Incentive Program?

Ultimately, the success of an incentive program depends on its ability to engage and motivate employees.

Employers should take the time to get to know their staff, understand what motivates them, and design an effective reward system, one that can help them achieve both individual and organizational success.

By creating a culture where staff feels appreciated for their hard work and dedication, businesses can inspire greater engagement levels among their workforce — ultimately leading to better overall performance. With the right incentive program in place, employers can reap the benefits of increased employee loyalty and satisfaction …while also improving the bottom-line

Cash Incentive vs Non-cash Incentive – Creating the Right Incentive Program

You’ve now researched the difference between a cash incentive vs non-cash incentive, it’s now time to develop your company’s incentive program.

The final piece of research for you might be to check out our quick 15-minute demonstration of how our tailored, structured, and automated incentive program. Give it a try, or simply contact us to get professional advice based on your company’s aims and objectives.

Build your bonus plan

Speak with an expert to create your bonus plan