Retention bonuses have gained popularity as a tool for organizations to retain their top talent. While they can offer short-term benefits, it is important to evaluate their effectiveness and consider alternative strategies that may address the underlying causes of employee turnover. In this blog post, we will explore some reasons why retention bonuses are a bad idea and alternative solutions for enhancing employee retention.

What is a retention bonus?

What is a retention bonus

A retention bonus is a one-time payment that is given to an employee to encourage them to stay with the company for a specific period of time. Retention bonuses are often used in industries where there is high turnover, such as technology and healthcare.  Retention bonuses are typically paid out when an employee signs a new contract or agrees to stay with the company for a certain period of time. The bonus can be used to offset the cost of recruiting and training a new employee, or it can be used to reward an employee for their loyalty and contributions to the company.

Why retention bonuses are a bad idea and alternative solutions

Retention bonuses have become a popular tool for organizations seeking to retain their top talent. While they can be effective in certain situations, it is important to consider the potential downsides associated with these incentives. In this blog post, we will explore the drawbacks of retention bonuses and shed light on the factors that organizations should carefully consider before implementing such programs.

  1. Band-Aid Solution:
A suitcase with a bandaid on it

Retention bonuses often provide a temporary solution.  The top reason companies offer a retention bonus is to retain the employee for a longer period of time. While the promise of a financial incentive may convince employees to stay in the short term, it may not address the deeper issues that could be driving their desire to leave. If employees are dissatisfied with their work environment, lack growth opportunities, or experience poor leadership, a retention bonus is unlikely to resolve these concerns in the long run.

  • Unrealistic Expectations: Retention bonuses can create the expectation of ongoing financial incentives, leading employees to stay solely for the monetary rewards. This can hinder the development of a more meaningful connection between employees and the organization, based on shared values and career growth opportunities.
  • 2. Bandwidth for Equality and Fairness:

Implementing retention bonuses can create disparities within the organization. If certain individuals or departments are targeted for these bonuses while others are not, it can lead to feelings of inequality and unfair treatment. This will likely cause damage to the overall organizational culture, hinder teamwork, and break trust among employees.

  • 3. Distortion of Employee Motivation:

Retention bonuses may inadvertently shift the focus of employees from their intrinsic motivation to extrinsic rewards. When employees start staying with the organization primarily for financial gain, their commitment and dedication to their work may diminish. The sense of purpose and fulfillment derived from meaningful work can take a back seat to the pursuit of monetary incentives, potentially compromising productivity and innovation.

two men bouncing ideas off eachother.
  • 4. Financial Burden and Cost-Effectiveness:

Retention bonuses can impose a significant financial burden on organizations, especially if they are offered on an ongoing basis. Allocating resources to retention bonuses may limit the organization’s ability to invest in other areas that could contribute to employee satisfaction and long-term retention, such as professional development, pay for performance programs, or competitive compensation packages. This can lead to a missed opportunity to address the root causes of turnover and create a more engaging work environment.

Alternative Strategies for Employee Retention:

While retention bonuses may seem like an attractive solution to combat employee turnover, they often fall short in addressing the underlying causes of dissatisfaction and disengagement. Instead, organizations should focus on creating a positive work environment, implementing robust performance management systems, promoting work-life balance, fostering transparent communication, providing competitive compensation and benefits, and offering meaningful career development opportunities. By addressing these fundamental factors, organizations can create a supportive and engaging environment that attracts and retains top talent in the long run.

What to Do Instead of Retention Bonuses

If you are a company that is considering using retention bonuses and have heard negative feedback about them, there are a number of things you can do instead.

  • Increase salaries.
  • Provide opportunities for advancement.
  • Create a positive work environment.
  • Invest in employee development.

While above are some good ideas rather than a retention bonus, our favorite method is a performance based bonus plan.

What is a performance based bonus plan?

A performance-based bonus plan is a type of incentive plan that rewards employees for meeting or exceeding performance goals. Performance goals can be measured in a variety of ways, such as the number of units produced, the amount of revenue generated, or the cost savings achieved.

Performance-based bonus plans are often used in industries where productivity is a key factor in success. They can be a valuable way to motivate employees to work hard and to improve their performance.

In today’s competitive business landscape, organizations are constantly seeking ways to motivate and engage their employees. Performance-based bonus programs have emerged as a popular and effective tool for aligning employee efforts with organizational goals. In this blog post, we will explore the benefits of performance-based bonus programs and discuss how they can drive individual and organizational success.

  1. Encouraging Accountability and Results:

Performance-based bonus programs are designed to reward employees based on their individual or team achievements. By tying financial incentives to specific performance metrics and goals, organizations foster a culture of accountability. Employees become more focused and motivated to deliver exceptional results, knowing that their efforts will directly impact their bonus potential.

  • 2. Motivating High Performance:

Incentives play a powerful role in motivating employees to go above and beyond their regular responsibilities. Performance-based bonus programs provide a clear link between performance and rewards, inspiring employees to strive for excellence. When employees see a direct correlation between their efforts and financial incentives, it can ignite their drive to achieve outstanding results, leading to improved productivity and overall performance. With Plentive’s live performance dashboards employees can track their performance and targets all in one place. Employees love having a visual and tracking their progress.

One of the key advantages of performance-based bonus programs is their ability to align individual goals with organizational objectives. By setting clear performance targets that align with the company’s strategic priorities, employees understand how their work contributes to the overall success of the organization. This alignment promotes a sense of purpose and enhances employee engagement, as employees can see the direct impact of their efforts on the company’s performance. If you or your employees are having a hard time figuring out KPI’s. Download our guide to setting effective KPI’s here.

  • 4. Attracting and Retaining Top Talent:

Performance-based bonus programs can serve as a powerful tool for attracting and retaining high-performing employees. Top talent is often motivated by opportunities to be recognized and rewarded for their exceptional performance. By offering performance-based bonuses, organizations can differentiate themselves as employers of choice, creating a competitive advantage in the talent market.

  • 5. Continuous Improvement and Development:

Performance-based bonus programs encourage ongoing improvement and development. As employees strive to meet or exceed performance targets, they may seek opportunities to enhance their skills and knowledge. This pursuit of excellence benefits both the individual and the organization, as it fosters a culture of continuous learning and growth.  If you’re interested in building a bonus program, download our guide here.


While retention bonuses may seem like an attractive solution to combat employee turnover, it is crucial to carefully evaluate their potential downsides. They may provide a short-term fix, but they often fail to address the underlying issues that drive employee dissatisfaction and disengagement. Organizations should consider alternative strategies such as fostering a performance based bonus program. Performance-based bonus programs offer a powerful mechanism for driving individual and organizational success. By aligning employee efforts with strategic goals, motivating high performance, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement, organizations can unlock the potential of their workforce. When implemented effectively, performance-based bonus programs become a valuable tool for attracting, motivating, and retaining top talent, ultimately contributing to the long-term success of the organization. Looking to implement your own performance based bonus program that companies are loving? Schedule a Demo.

Build your bonus plan

Speak with an expert to create your bonus plan